An ongoing dispute between GlenWyvis founder John F Mckenzie and the current board of GlenWyvis directors, regarding the management of the land on which the distillery sits, has ended in court and arbitration proceedings.
To have to go to court against the business you started has been a bizarre experience
John F Mckenzie
What began as a community-focused initiative has turned into a living nightmare for John and his family, who now face the prospect of paying significant legal fees. Can you help John defend his farm?
Following the release of their 2024 business plan on 27th March and, despite clauses in the lease contracts designed to keep any disputes private, GlenWyvis Distillery chose to send their large membership (which includes journalists and politicians) correspondence with only their side of the story. Bringing matters to the public's attention, John has responded by telling his side of the story and publicly defending his farm.
The information below is in the public interest, GlenWyvis Distillery has received money from Highlands and Islands Enterprise, both businesses are public.
John resigned in 2019 as volunteer Managing Director due to David O'Connor, chairperson at the time, violating board instruction. (This was minuted and has been reported to the society as a breach of rules and lease - the rules provide for the chairperson to chair meetings, nothing more.) O'Connor, a former police commander at Dingwall (retired in 2013) had started a separate business, Ross Shire Lettings Ltd, on 8th January 2018 with Hazel Allen, the Finance Director employed by the distillery at the time (also putting her in breach of contract, society rules and lease). This business arrangement was never declared at any board meeting. Unbeknown to the local committee, that business arrangement was the subject of litigation at Inverness sheriff court in 2019.
Justice for the McCulloch brothers, the rightful owners of Logie Farm Sign the petition
Another business, Muir of Allangrange Ltd, started by O'Connor on 8th July 2018, instigated the development and the purchase of Logie Farmhouse and Logie Farm from the neighbour of the distillery, Reverend Ivan Warwick. This property was also the subject of litigation and has been covered widely in the press.
Complicating matters further, Neil Boyle, the bank manager at Bank of Scotland for both John and the distillery, became the tenant of Logie Farmhouse (unbeknown to John). A complaint was lodged with the bank about Boyle's position as tenant of Logie Farm (owned by O'Connor) - a clear conflict of interest. The details were reported to independent Committee on Standards in Public Life and investigations are ongoing since information came to light in 2022.
An audit in summer 2019 revealed these serious conflicts of interest and John resigned as a director shortly after and before the fire of Oct 2019.
In 2022 further information came to light through the public court process and an official complaint was made to the Distillery standards committee, which John instigated the set up of in 2021 during mediation. Part of the the standards committee remit is to ensure democratic processes after O'Connor became chairman of the Goodwill committee in 2020 without any formal elections having been held. O'Connor finished as a director of the distillery in Nov 2019 and did not put himself forward for election to the Goodwill fund committee in 2021.
To date no response has been issued by the society on these important matters.
For 6 years John has been fighting to obtain financial disclosure on all matters relating to GlenWyvis Distillery - these high profile cases show why that was necessary - yet, despite legal orders to do so, the distillery refuses. The distillery committee has instead preferred to spend vast sums of community money through various courts to try to stop financial disclosure.
We believe the time has come for all members of GlenWyvis Distillery to vote through a special members meeting on enforcing that the committee disclose to the members all financial information in its possession, including how much has been spent on legal fees to date, along with minutes of any bond holder meetings, for all members to read prior to agm June 2025.
A petition will be available shortly for signature, and will be presented to GlenWyvis Distillery management committee in line with democratic special members meeting protocols.
The 2024 business plan promised a wind turbine for the distillery, along with new warehouses close to Dingwall. The community share offer that was planned for and advertised to investors in 2016 for the (already designed) visitor centre (a venture that would have had a dramatic impact on the entrance to Dingwall and the wider town, including the high street) was not progressed following David Grahams involvement in 2019. For reasons unknown, Inchberry, 20 miles from Dingwall, became the preferred location for the development of new warehouses.
Let's not forget what could have been. Here's the original plans for the visitor centre.
Keep an eye out here for more updates.
Dingwall Whisky Distillery Trust
c/o GlenWyvis Farmhouse
Upper Dochcarty
Dingwall
Ross-Shire
IV15 9UF